Homemade vs Store Bought Baby Food

Homemade vs Store Bought Baby Food

Not already a member? Join now for free to get more exclusive #LDJ stories?

“Just talk to other people, because you’ll actually find out that things are different, for every baby and every couple.”

Whether you’re intending to make it all from scratch, or embrace the ease of store bought, there’s no right or wrong way when it comes to the food your baby eats.

As you embark on the messy and marvellous journey of weaning, we’ll try to answer some of the questions you might have about homemade baby food vs store bought. You’ll also hear from other families who have learned to follow their instincts and do what’s best for them at every mealtime.

love don't judge

Looking for support, not judgement?

We'll give you the reassurance you need to parent your way.

Is store bought baby food bad for my child?

The simple answer is no1. Whilst there have been numerous discussions about how appropriate it is to feed your baby store bought food, there’s no concrete evidence to suggest that it’s ‘bad’ for your child. What’s important is that your child receives the important nutrients they need. Whether they get that from store bought or homemade baby food, you’re providing your baby with the building blocks for their future growth and development.

If you’re concerned about the contents of store bought as opposed to homemade baby food, read the list of ingredients to put your mind at rest. Make sure that you’re happy with everything that your chosen baby food contains. The good news is that there’s so much choice available. So if you’re unhappy with a particular brand, there’ll be plenty others for you to choose from.

In addition, you could consider using a mix of store bought and homemade baby food, which will help you find the perfect balance for you, your baby and your family life.

Homemade baby food vs store bought

“Take the information, but not necessarily feel judged by it all the time”.

As with all things parenting, it’s about weighing up the pros and the cons.

When it comes to homemade baby food, the biggest pro by far is the fact that you have full control over what goes into it. There’s also a lot more flexibility as you experiment with different recipes and ingredients. Ultimately, it’s cheaper, too2.

If you’re thinking about baby-led weaning homemade baby food is a great way to get your little food monster involved in the preparation. They’ll soon be familiar with all of the different foods you intend to introduce them to as you cook up a storm.

Store bought baby food has its upsides too. Parenthood can be a busy time, and the convenience that store bought baby food offers is hard to ignore. Simply pop it in your baby bag and off you go (just be sure not to forget your spoon)! Homemade baby food takes time and energy to prepare. Not to mention a whole lot of tupperware and endless freezer space! For many families, store bought baby food is the more convenient choice across the board.

Babies get hungry, and sometimes you won’t always be in the comfort of your own home when they need to be fed.

Let’s make one thing clear; however you choose to feed your baby, you should never be made to feel uncomfortable about doing so. In fact, if you’re breastfeeding your baby in a public place such as in a shop, on public transport or in a cafe, it’s actually illegal for anyone to ask you to stop doing so, or to leave4.

Homemade baby food vs store bought: does it matter how it’s made? 

This is a big question for any parent wrestling with the homemade baby food vs store bought conundrum.

Many parents worry about preservatives in store bought baby food, and it’s true that these won’t be found in homemade baby food. When you go homemade, you’re in full control when it comes to knowing exactly what your baby is eating. There’s also no getting away from the fact that store bought food is processed, which can result in its nutritional benefits being undermined3.

But for each of these downsides, there’s also an upside. The fact that homemade baby food doesn’t contain preservatives means that it doesn’t last as long. It will need to be refrigerated or frozen within hours of preparation to avoid contamination from bacteria. And whilst store bought baby food is processed, this ensures that any bacteria are killed way before your baby gets to savour every last mouthful. 

Ultimately, it’s apples and oranges. And the decision is yours.

jake graf

Homemade vs Store bought - fed is best

“The main thing is that they’re happy and healthy”.

The thing about parenting, is that it’s very easy to have ideas and hopes for how your particular journey is going to look. But the real adventure is taking each day as it comes and following your instincts.

Both homemade and store bought baby foods have their pros and cons. It’s about finding the balance that works for you. Ultimately, it comes down to what you want from your weaning adventure. And remember that at the end of the day, all that matters is that your baby gets the nutrition they need to grow healthily and happily.

Take a look at how we’re committed to #LoveDon'tJudge

As we continue to call out parental judgement, explore some of our other articles that show how we’re doing just that.

baby development

Baby development: crawling & walking

From crawling and walking, to chatterbox talking, learn about your baby’s development.

parental leave

Feeling judged on my family size


Whatever the size of your family, you shouldn't feel judged. Here’s what we’re saying about family size.

Parental leave

Parental leave: feeling guilty and lonely

Take a look at our view on gender roles and hear from the families who are doing things their way.

baby on picnic blanket

A community that knows how to #LoveDon'tJudge

Explore the C&G baby club community to find out what the media and other families are saying about the #LoveDontJudge campaign. Calling time on parental judgement never felt so good!

Read more about how to help your baby love the food they eat.

a father assembling a crib

How to start weaning

Explore our top tips for an enjoyable weaning experience.

a couple laying down on the bed looking at a cell phone

How to prepare, store & reheat baby food

Read our handy guidance on how to prepare, store and reheat baby food.

two dads

Winding your baby

Our complete guide to winding your baby.
 

Share your #LoveDontJudge story and discover what other parents are saying

Need some friendly advice or a bit of reassurance?

Ask us a question (8am - 8pm Monday to Friday, 10am - 4pm Weekends)

WhatsApp

Messenger

Contact us on Facebook (10am - 10pm, 7 days a week)

Call us

Call us on 0800 977 8880 (8am - 8pm Monday to Friday)

FAQs

Get answers to your most frequently asked questions

x